Quick answer: Check the contractor’s business identity, verify locally required credentials through the issuing authority, confirm insurance documentation, contact references and review a detailed written contract. Do not treat a badge, review score or salesperson’s promise as verification. Compare written estimates before committing. (consumer.ftc.gov)
This guide is for U.S. homeowners. California provides the specific regulatory examples below; those rules should not be applied nationwide. Check requirements where the property is located. California guidance was checked on November 22, 2026.
1. Establish exactly who would be taking your money
Before comparing prices, request the contractor’s legal business name, business address, telephone number and applicable license or registration number. These details should appear consistently in the proposed agreement. The FTC recommends including the contractor’s identifying information in the contract. (consumer.ftc.gov)
Create a simple verification sheet with columns for the name shown on the estimate, official credential record and insurance documents. Ask the contractor to explain any mismatch before you proceed.
Also confirm who the salesperson represents. California’s Department of Insurance advises homeowners to contact the contractor if someone claiming to represent the business cannot establish that authority. Use independently verified business contact information for that check. (insurance.ca.gov)
Practical questions:
- Which legal business will sign the contract?
- Is the advertised name a trading name for that business?
- Who is authorized to approve contract changes?
- Which business should appear as the payment recipient?
Treat unexplained inconsistencies as unresolved questions—not automatic proof of fraud.
2. Verify credentials through the official authority
Start with your state or local government, not a directory advertisement. Requirements vary by jurisdiction. Ask the licensing authority or building department which credentials apply to the proposed roofing work. Iowa’s attorney general also cautions that contractor registration does not guarantee good workmanship. (consumer.ftc.gov)
California example: The Contractors State License Board, or CSLB, provides an official search by license number, business name or personnel name. California identifies C-39 as its roofing-contractor classification. Check that the credential and contracting arrangement fit the actual work; ask CSLB about unclear classifications or subcontracting arrangements. (cslb.ca.gov)
When reviewing the record, ask:
- Does the business identity match the proposal?
- Is the license currently active?
- Does the classification cover the proposed scope?
- Are there public disciplinary disclosures or other restrictions to investigate?
Save a dated copy of what you checked. CSLB notes that its public information includes license, bond and workers’ compensation status, along with certain legal actions. (cslb.ca.gov)
A manufacturer badge or trade-association membership is a separate claim. Do not use it instead of checking the government credential required for your location.
3. Check insurance documents, not just “fully insured”
Ask for evidence of commercial general liability insurance and applicable workers’ compensation coverage. California’s insurance department recommends requesting a certificate showing the insurer, policy number and limits, then contacting the insurer directly to verify the information. (insurance.ca.gov)
Use this document-review checklist:
| Item | Question to resolve |
|---|---|
| Insured business | Does it correspond to the business contracting with you? |
| Insurer and policy number | Can the issuer verify the documentation? |
| Effective and expiration dates | Will the stated coverage period include the planned work? |
| Coverage and limits | What protection is actually provided, and what remains unclear? |
| Subcontractors | Who will perform the work, and how will their insurance be verified? |
California’s workers’ compensation documentation requirements include the business name, policy number, coverage dates and an authorized signature. (cslb.ca.gov)
A certificate is evidence of insurance, not the policy itself. It does not expand coverage or override exclusions. Ask your own insurance professional about unresolved coverage questions rather than assuming a certificate guarantees payment for any accident or damage. (permarisk.gov)
California roofing check: Active C-39 contractors must carry workers’ compensation insurance or an accepted certification of self-insurance even without employees. “I work alone” is therefore not a sufficient explanation for missing documentation. (cslb.ca.gov)
4. Contact references and read reviews critically
Ask for references you can actually contact. California’s homeowner checklist recommends obtaining at least three local references and speaking with them. The FTC also recommends checking complaints and reading online reviews critically. (cslb.ca.gov)
For a useful conversation, ask more than “Were you happy?”
- What roofing work was included?
- Did the final invoice match the agreed scope and approved changes?
- How were delays communicated?
- Were the property and access routes left clean?
- If a problem arose, how did the contractor respond?
- Would you hire the business again, and why?
These questions are a suggested interview framework, not a scoring system. Note specific answers and follow up on vague ones.
Search the business name with terms such as “complaint” and “scam,” but investigate what you find rather than treating every accusation as established fact. Equally, a lack of visible complaints should not replace identity, insurance and contract checks. (consumer.ftc.gov)
5. Compare the written scope before comparing totals
Get multiple written estimates. Iowa’s attorney general warns against unusually low bids that do not explain the materials, labor or scope. Its guidance calls for written details covering price, timing, permits, inspections, cleanup and change orders. (iowaattorneygeneral.gov)
For roofing, use the following as a comparison worksheet, asking each bidder to mark items included, excluded or unresolved:
| Scope item | What to ask the bidder to state |
|---|---|
| Existing roofing | What removal and disposal are included? |
| New materials | What manufacturer, product line and material specifications are proposed? |
| Decking | What is included, and how would additional work be priced? |
| Flashing and penetrations | Which components would be replaced, retained or excluded? |
| Ventilation | What work is proposed, if any? |
| Permits and inspections | Who obtains them, and are fees included? |
| Property protection | What protection and access arrangements are agreed? |
| Cleanup | Who removes debris and checks for loose fasteners? |
| Warranties | What written terms will be supplied? |
These are questions to resolve, not a universal roofing specification. CSLB advises making material descriptions specific and putting agreed cleanup and debris removal in the contract. (cslb.ca.gov)
Ask the local building department about permit requirements. Do not accept an unexplained claim that permits or inspections are unnecessary. (iowaattorneygeneral.gov)

6. Review deposits and payment milestones
Check local deposit rules before agreeing to a percentage. Avoid paying the entire job upfront, use traceable payments and obtain receipts. Iowa’s attorney general recommends those precautions; the FTC’s home-repair guidance also warns against cash and wire-transfer payments. (iowaattorneygeneral.gov)
California’s ordinary home-improvement rule: The down payment cannot exceed $1,000 or 10% of the contract price, whichever is less. CSLB identifies an exception for contractors with a qualifying Blanket Performance and Payment Bond on file. Verify any claimed exception with CSLB. (cslb.ca.gov)
Worked example—illustrative amounts in U.S. dollars, not a roofing price estimate:
A hypothetical California roofing contract totals $20,000 and requests $4,000 as a down payment.
- Ten percent of $20,000 is $2,000.
- The lesser of $2,000 and $1,000 is $1,000.
- Under the ordinary rule, the proposed $4,000 down payment exceeds the limit.
Do not sign that payment provision without correction or official confirmation that a valid exception applies. (cslb.ca.gov)
For later installments, ask what completed work makes each payment due. California’s checklist advises paying as work is completed rather than beforehand. (cslb.ca.gov)
7. Agree on changes, cleanup and closeout
Resolve how unexpected work will be handled before the roof project starts. Ask the contractor to describe the documentation, pricing and approval process for additional decking or other work outside the original scope.
Request a written change order stating:
- What is changing and why.
- Supporting documentation, where available.
- The added cost or credit.
- Any effect on the completion date.
- Both parties’ approval.
CSLB advises recording changes to work, materials, price and timing in a signed change order that becomes part of the contract. It also recommends including complete cleanup and removal of debris and materials in the original agreement. (cslb.ca.gov)
Before signing, propose a closeout checklist covering remaining work, agreed cleanup, inspection documentation where applicable, warranty paperwork and the final invoice. Clarify who supplies each item.
Keep a project file containing the contract, approved changes, insurance documents, invoices, payment records and correspondence. California’s insurance department specifically recommends maintaining those records. (insurance.ca.gov)

8. Use a final signing checklist—and pause under pressure
The FTC identifies immediate-decision pressure, leftover-material offers and demands for full upfront payment as warning signs. It also warns homeowners against signing financing documents they have not read or do not understand. (consumer.ftc.gov)
Before signing, make sure you can answer:
- Identity: Which business is legally responsible for the job?
- Credentials: Have I verified the requirements and current official record?
- Insurance: Have I checked documents and resolved coverage questions?
- References: Have I spoken with previous customers?
- Scope: Are materials, exclusions, timing and responsibilities written down?
- Payments: Are the deposit and milestones clear and locally permissible?
- Changes: Must additional work receive documented approval?
- Closeout: What must be delivered before final payment?
Also ask the relevant consumer agency which cancellation rights apply to your particular agreement. California’s checklist explicitly prompts homeowners to verify whether cancellation rights apply; do not assume every contract has the same cancellation window. (cslb.ca.gov)
Do not sign blank spaces or rely on a promise to add important terms later. Keep the completed agreement and attachments. CSLB cautions that even an authorization to proceed can become the contract, so review what a document permits—not merely its title. (cslb.ca.gov)